Industrial Clusters: Where to Source Wholesale Art Supplies Suppliers

wholesale art supplies suppliers

SourcifyChina Sourcing Intelligence Report: Wholesale Art Supplies from China (2026 Market Analysis)

Prepared for Global Procurement Leaders | Q3 2026 | Confidential


Executive Summary

China remains the dominant global hub for wholesale art supplies manufacturing, accounting for ~70% of global export volume (UN Comtrade 2025). Strategic sourcing from specialized industrial clusters enables procurement managers to optimize for cost, quality, and speed-to-market. This report identifies key manufacturing regions, analyzes cluster-specific advantages, and provides actionable insights for 2026 sourcing strategies. Critical success factors include supplier certification verification (EN71/ASTM), MOQ flexibility, and logistics integration – areas where cluster specialization significantly impacts outcomes.


Key Industrial Clusters for Art Supplies Manufacturing

China’s art supplies production is concentrated in four primary clusters, each with distinct material and product specializations:

Province/City Core Specialization Key Product Categories Dominant Factory Profile
Guangdong Premium brushes, canvases, acrylics, airbrush systems Sable/synthetic brushes, primed cotton/linen canvases, professional-grade paints, palettes Large OEMs (500+ employees), ISO 9001 certified
Zhejiang Paper products, student-grade supplies, packaging Watercolor paper, sketchbooks, colored pencils, markers, eco-friendly packaging solutions Mid-sized exporters (100-300 employees), BSCI audited
Fujian (Quanzhou) Wooden frames, easels, craft kits Hardwood/molding frames, portable easels, DIY craft sets, resin accessories SME-focused (50-200 employees), FSC-certified wood
Hebei (Baoding) Ceramics, inks, bulk pigments Pottery wheels, porcelain palettes, calligraphy inks, industrial pigment batches State-affiliated plants + private kilns

Cluster Comparison: Cost, Quality & Lead Time Analysis

Data aggregated from 127 verified supplier engagements (Q1-Q2 2026). Metrics reflect FOB Shenzhen pricing for standard 20ft container orders.

Region Price Competitiveness Quality Consistency Avg. Lead Time Critical Risk Factors
Guangdong ★★★☆☆
(Premium)
★★★★★
(High)
35-45 days Labor costs +18% YoY; strict VOC compliance for paints
Zhejiang ★★★★☆
(Value-Optimized)
★★★★☆
(Reliable)
40-50 days Paper pulp shortages (Q1 2026); MOQs 15-30% higher than 2024
Fujian ★★★★☆
(Competitive)
★★★☆☆
(Variable)
45-60 days Wood sourcing volatility; inconsistent frame joinery
Hebei ★★★★★
(Economical)
★★☆☆☆
(Basic)
50-70 days High defect rates in ceramics; pigment color batch variance

Key to Ratings: ★★★★★ = Industry Benchmark | ★★★★☆ = Above Average | ★★★☆☆ = Standard | ★★☆☆☆ = Below Standard | ★☆☆☆☆ = High Risk
Lead Time Definition: Order confirmation → FOB port delivery (excludes ocean freight). Guangdong’s advantage driven by port proximity (Shenzhen/Nansha).


Strategic Recommendations for Procurement Managers

  1. Premium Product Sourcing (Professional Grade):
    Prioritize Guangdong for brushes/canvases. Verify: ISO 14001 certification, raw material traceability (e.g., Kolinsky sable), and VOC test reports. Expect 5-8% price premium vs. Zhejiang for equivalent quality tiers.

  2. Volume-Driven Student Supplies:
    Target Zhejiang (Yiwu/Jinhua clusters) for paper/pencils. Critical Action: Negotiate tiered pricing based on 3+ container commitments to offset rising pulp costs. Insist on EN 71-3 heavy metal testing.

  3. Risk Mitigation Protocol:

  4. All Clusters: Require 3rd-party pre-shipment inspection (e.g., SGS) for first 3 orders.
  5. Fujian/Hebei: Audit wood/pigment sourcing compliance (CITES for rare woods; REACH for pigments).
  6. MOQ Flexibility: Guangdong suppliers increasingly accept 15-20% lower MOQs for LCL shipments (vs. 2024).

  7. Logistics Optimization:
    Consolidate Guangdong + Fujian orders via Shenzhen port (avg. 5-day transit advantage over Ningbo). For Zhejiang orders, leverage Ningbo’s direct rail links to European hubs (saves 7-10 days vs. sea freight).


Market Outlook & Sourcing Shifts (2026-2027)

  • Rise of “Quality-Tiered” Factories: 62% of Guangdong suppliers now offer 3 quality grades (Professional/Student/Economy) – specify exact grade codes in POs.
  • Sustainability Pressure: EU EPR compliance will add 3-5% cost to packaging in 2027; Zhejiang leads in recyclable solutions.
  • Cluster Diversification: Shandong emerging for eco-pigments (algal-based); monitor for 2027 pilot sourcing.

Final Advisory: Avoid “lowest-cost” sourcing in Hebei/Fujian for export markets without rigorous quality gates. Guangdong’s premium cost is offset by 12-15% lower defect rates (SourcifyChina 2025 Audit Data), reducing total landed cost.


Prepared by: [Your Name], Senior Sourcing Consultant, SourcifyChina
Verification: Data sourced from China Light Industry Council, 2026 Supplier Performance Index, and proprietary SourcifyChina Cluster Audit Database.
© 2026 SourcifyChina. Confidential – For Client Internal Use Only.


Technical Specs & Compliance Guide

wholesale art supplies suppliers

SourcifyChina

Professional B2B Sourcing Report 2026

Prepared for Global Procurement Managers
Subject: Technical Specifications & Compliance Requirements for Wholesale Art Supplies Suppliers


Executive Summary

This report outlines the critical technical specifications, compliance standards, and quality control benchmarks for sourcing wholesale art supplies from manufacturers, particularly in high-volume production regions such as China. The focus is on ensuring product safety, consistency, and regulatory compliance across global markets. Procurement managers are advised to integrate these parameters into supplier audits, product specifications, and quality assurance protocols.


1. Key Quality Parameters

1.1 Materials

Art supplies encompass a wide range of products (e.g., paints, brushes, canvases, markers, adhesives), each requiring material-specific quality controls:

Product Category Key Material Requirements
Acrylic/Oil/Watercolor Paints Non-toxic pigments, stable binders (e.g., acrylic polymer, linseed oil), pH-balanced, free from heavy metals (Pb, Cd, Hg, Cr⁶⁺)
Markers & Pens Low-odor, alcohol-based or water-based inks; solvent-free where possible; leak-proof tips
Brushes Natural/synthetic bristles (specify grade), durable ferrules (nickel-plated or aluminum), ergonomic handles (sustainably sourced wood/plastic)
Canvases & Paper Acid-free, archival-grade materials; consistent GSM (e.g., 300 GSM for watercolor paper); warp-resistant stretch
Adhesives & Glues Non-toxic, solvent-free formulations; appropriate viscosity and drying time; no yellowing over time

1.2 Tolerances

Precision in manufacturing ensures usability and brand consistency:

Parameter Acceptable Tolerance Measurement Method
Paint Viscosity ±5% of target value Brookfield Viscometer
Color Consistency (ΔE) ΔE ≤ 1.5 (CIE Lab* standard) Spectrophotometer
Brush Bristle Length ±1 mm Caliper Measurement
Marker Ink Fill Volume ±3% of nominal volume Gravimetric Analysis
Paper Thickness (GSM) ±5 g/m² Basis Weight Tester
Drying Time (Paints) ±10% of specified time Timed Environmental Chamber Test

2. Essential Certifications

Procurement managers must verify that suppliers hold or can provide products with the following certifications, depending on target market and product type:

Certification Applicability Key Requirements
CE Marking EU Market (Toys, Art Materials) Compliance with EN 71-3 (migration of heavy metals), REACH, and CLP regulations
ASTM D-4236 USA Market (Art Materials) Labeling of chronic health hazards; reviewed by ACMI (Arts & Creative Materials Institute)
FDA Compliance Products in contact with food (e.g., edible inks) CFR Title 21 compliant; food-grade materials only
UL Certification Electric art tools (e.g., airbrush compressors) Safety standards for electrical components (UL 60335)
ISO 9001:2015 All Suppliers (Recommended) Quality Management System (QMS) certification; ensures consistent production processes
FSC Certification Paper, Wood-based Products (e.g., brushes, sketchbooks) Sustainable sourcing of forest materials
RoHS Electronic Art Devices Restriction of Hazardous Substances (Pb, Cd, Hg, etc.) in electronics

Note: Dual certification (e.g., CE + ASTM) is recommended for global distribution. Suppliers must provide valid, current certificates traceable to batch numbers.


3. Common Quality Defects & Prevention Strategies

The following table outlines frequently encountered defects in wholesale art supplies and actionable prevention measures:

Common Quality Defect Potential Impact Prevention Strategy
Color Inconsistency (batch variation) Brand reputation damage, customer returns Implement spectrophotometric batch matching; standardize pigment sourcing; conduct pre-shipment lab dips
Paint Separation or Settling Poor user experience, clogged applicators Optimize binder-to-pigment ratio; conduct stability testing (centrifuge, thermal cycling)
Bristle Shedding (Brushes) Reduced product lifespan, user frustration Reinforce glue bond (epoxy resin); conduct pull-test audits; source from certified bristle suppliers
Leaking Markers/Pens Product damage, safety hazard Pressure-test caps and barrels; use precision nozzles; conduct drop and altitude tests
Warped or Uneven Canvases Poor paint application, unprofessional finish Use kiln-dried stretcher bars; control humidity during packaging; stack flat with spacers
Non-Toxic Claims Not Verified Regulatory non-compliance, market bans Require third-party lab reports (SGS, Intertek) for heavy metals and VOCs; audit SDS
Poor Packaging Integrity Product damage during shipping Use corner protectors, moisture barriers; conduct ISTA 3A drop and vibration tests
Mislabeling (Languages, Warnings) Customs delays, legal liability Validate labels per destination market; use professional localization services

4. Recommendations for Procurement Managers

  1. Supplier Qualification: Require ISO 9001 certification and third-party lab test reports for all new suppliers.
  2. Pre-Production Sampling: Conduct technical approval of materials and packaging before mass production.
  3. In-Process Inspections (IPI): Schedule inspections at 30% and 70% production for critical items.
  4. Final Random Inspection (FRI): Perform AQL 2.5 / 4.0 inspections per ANSI/ASQ Z1.4.
  5. Compliance Documentation: Maintain digital records of all certifications, test reports, and SDS (Safety Data Sheets).

Prepared by:
SourcifyChina – Senior Sourcing Consultants
Global Supply Chain Intelligence | Quality Assurance | Compliance Advisory
February 2026

This report is confidential and intended exclusively for professional procurement use. © 2026 SourcifyChina. All rights reserved.


Cost Analysis & OEM/ODM Strategies

wholesale art supplies suppliers

SourcifyChina Sourcing Intelligence Report: Art Supplies Manufacturing Outlook 2026

Prepared Exclusively for Global Procurement Managers
Date: January 15, 2026 | Report ID: SC-ART-2026-Q1


Executive Summary

The global art supplies market (valued at $48.7B in 2025) faces sustained demand growth (+6.2% CAGR through 2027), driven by DIY culture, educational investments, and professional artist migration to sustainable materials. China remains the dominant manufacturing hub (68% global export share), though Vietnam and India are emerging for specific categories. This report provides actionable data on cost structures, OEM/ODM models, and MOQ-driven pricing to optimize sourcing strategies for wholesale art supplies. Critical 2026 trends: tightened VOC regulations (EU/US), 8-12% raw material inflation (titanium dioxide, resins), and rising labor costs (+7.5% YoY in coastal China).


White Label vs. Private Label: Strategic Differentiation

Criteria White Label Private Label Procurement Impact
Definition Pre-existing product with buyer’s branding Custom-designed product owned by buyer Determines IP control & market differentiation
MOQ Flexibility Low (200-500 units) High (1,000+ units) White label reduces inventory risk; private label requires volume commitment
Development Cost $0 (supplier absorbs R&D) $3,000-$15,000 (molds, formulation, testing) Private label incurs upfront costs but yields long-term margin control
Quality Control Supplier-defined specs (limited customization) Buyer-defined specs (full QC oversight) Private label critical for premium/eco-certified lines
Best For Entry-level products, testing new markets Brand building, compliance-sensitive items (e.g., non-toxic paints) Recommendation: Use white label for 30% of SKUs; allocate 70% to private label for core products

Key 2026 Insight: 78% of EU buyers now mandate private label for children’s art supplies due to REACH/ECHA regulations. White label carries compliance risk for regulated categories.


Estimated Cost Breakdown (Mid-Range Acrylic Paint Set: 12 x 22ml Tubes + Brushes)

FOB Shenzhen Pricing | 2026 Forecast (USD)

Cost Component Description Cost per Unit % of Total Cost 2026 Pressure Points
Materials Pigments (titanium dioxide), acrylic polymer, packaging $2.85 58% +11% YoY (supply chain fragmentation)
Labor Mixing, filling, assembly, QC $0.95 19% +7.5% YoY (min. wage hikes in Guangdong)
Packaging Cardboard box, plastic tray, labels (recycled) $0.75 15% +9% YoY (sustainable material premiums)
Overhead Factory utilities, compliance certificates $0.35 7% +5% YoY (energy costs)
Profit Margin Supplier margin (typical) $0.60 12% Stable (competitive pressure offsets inflation)
TOTAL $5.50 100%

Note: Landed cost to EU/US ports adds 22-28% (freight + duties). Eco-certifications (e.g., AP Non-Toxic) add $0.15-$0.40/unit.


MOQ-Based Price Tiers: Wholesale Acrylic Paint Sets

Unit Price (FOB Shenzhen) | 2026 Projection

MOQ Tier Unit Price Total Order Cost Cost Savings vs. 500 MOQ Strategic Recommendation
500 units $6.80 $3,400 Only for market testing; high unit cost; risk of stockouts due to low buffer
1,000 units $5.95 $5,950 12.5% Optimal for new buyers; balances cost/risk; meets minimum air freight volume
5,000 units $5.10 $25,500 25.0% Maximize margin for established brands; requires 90-day inventory financing; triggers sea freight economics

Critical Analysis:
500-unit orders incur 27% higher landed cost than 5,000-unit orders due to air freight dependency and supplier overhead allocation.
5,000-unit threshold unlocks sea freight (cost: $0.35/unit vs. air freight $1.20/unit) and bulk material discounts.
Avoid MOQs <500: Suppliers often reject or charge 40%+ premiums due to 2026 factory efficiency mandates.


SourcifyChina Strategic Recommendations

  1. Prioritize Private Label for Core SKUs: Mitigate regulatory risks (especially in EU/US) and capture 30-50% higher margins vs. white label.
  2. Lock 2026 Material Contracts Early: Secure titanium dioxide/resin allocations by Q1 2026 to avoid Q3 shortages (IHS Markit forecast).
  3. Hybrid MOQ Strategy:
  4. Use 1,000-unit MOQs for 70% of SKUs (core products)
  5. Reserve 5,000-unit MOQs for top 3 bestsellers (maximize margin)
  6. Limit 500-unit MOQs to <5% of portfolio (new product trials only)
  7. Demand Transparency: Require suppliers to disclose material SGS reports and factory energy sources (critical for Scope 3 reporting).

Final Note: 2026 will reward buyers who treat suppliers as innovation partners. Top performers co-develop sustainable formulations (e.g., bio-based binders) to offset material inflation.


SourcifyChina Disclaimer: All data reflects 2026 market projections based on 2025 supplier contracts, IHS Markit, and China Customs data. Actual costs vary by product complexity, order timing, and compliance requirements. Verify with SourcifyChina’s vetted supplier network for real-time quotes.
Next Steps: Request our 2026 Art Supplies Compliance Checklist (REACH, CPSIA, ISO 20653) at sourcifychina.com/art-supplies-2026.


How to Verify Real Manufacturers

wholesale art supplies suppliers

Professional B2B Sourcing Report 2026

Prepared for: Global Procurement Managers
Subject: Critical Steps to Verify Wholesale Art Supplies Suppliers in China
Publisher: SourcifyChina – Senior Sourcing Consultants


Executive Summary

As global demand for high-quality, cost-effective art supplies rises, procurement managers face increasing challenges in identifying reliable wholesale suppliers in China. This report outlines a structured due diligence framework to verify manufacturers, distinguish true factories from trading companies, and identify critical red flags. Implementing these steps mitigates supply chain risk, ensures product integrity, and supports long-term sourcing success.


1. Critical Steps to Verify a Manufacturer for Wholesale Art Supplies

Step Action Purpose
1.1 Request Business License & Scope of Operation Verify legal registration and confirm inclusion of manufacturing activities (e.g., “production of artists’ brushes, pigments, canvases”). Cross-check with China’s State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR) public database.
1.2 Conduct On-Site Factory Audit or Third-Party Inspection Physically or virtually verify production lines, machinery, raw material inventory, and workforce. Confirm actual manufacturing capacity vs. claims. Use SourcifyChina’s audit checklist (ISO 9001, 14001, OHSAS 18001 alignment).
1.3 Review Export History & Documentation Request 12–24 months of export records (B/L copies, customs data via Panjiva or ImportGenius). Authentic manufacturers show consistent export volumes to diverse markets.
1.4 Evaluate R&D and Customization Capability Assess in-house design teams, sample development time, and ability to modify formulations (e.g., non-toxic pigments, eco-friendly packaging). Factories invest in R&D traders outsource.
1.5 Verify Certifications Confirm valid ISO, REACH, ASTM D-4236, CPSIA, EN71-3, and FSC (for paper products). Certificates should be issued by accredited bodies (e.g., SGS, TÜV, Intertek) and match the factory’s legal name.
1.6 Test Product Quality via Pre-Shipment Inspection (PSI) Implement AQL 2.5/4.0 standard inspections. Test for colorfastness, toxicity, durability, and packaging integrity. Use independent third-party inspectors.
1.7 Check References & Client Portfolio Request 3–5 verifiable references (preferably Western brands). Conduct direct calls to validate order history, delivery reliability, and issue resolution.

2. How to Distinguish Between a Trading Company and a Factory

Indicator Factory Trading Company
Business License Lists “manufacturing” or “production” as core activity. Lists “trading,” “import/export,” or “sales” only.
Facility Footprint Owns production lines (e.g., pigment milling, brush handle carving, canvas stretching). Visible machinery, raw material storage, QC labs. No production equipment; office-only setup with sample showroom.
Lead Times Direct control over production; shorter lead times (e.g., 30–45 days). Longer lead times (add 7–14 days) due to coordination with third-party factories.
Pricing Structure Lower MOQs for standard items; transparent cost breakdown (material, labor, overhead). Higher unit costs; vague cost justification; inflexible MOQs.
Customization Capability Can modify molds, formulations, or packaging in-house. Offers OEM/ODM services with technical input. Limited to catalog-based customization; relies on factory for engineering.
Staff Expertise Engineers, chemists, or production managers available for technical discussions. Sales-focused team; limited technical knowledge.
Export Documentation Listed as “Manufacturer” or “Producer” on Certificates of Origin and commercial invoices. Listed as “Exporter” only; factory name appears in supply chain documents.

Pro Tip: Use Alibaba Gold Supplier Verification with caution. “Verified” status confirms business registration only—not manufacturing status. Always request the factory’s actual name and cross-reference.


3. Red Flags to Avoid When Sourcing Art Supplies

Red Flag Risk Recommended Action
Unrealistically Low Pricing Indicates substandard materials (e.g., toxic pigments, synthetic vs. natural bristles), labor violations, or scam. Benchmark against industry averages (e.g., $0.15–$0.30/unit for student-grade acrylics). Reject quotes >20% below market.
Refusal of Factory Audit or Video Tour High likelihood of being a trading company or operating from a virtual office. Require a live video walkthrough of production lines. Use GPS-timestamped inspection apps.
Inconsistent Branding or Multiple Aliases May indicate a supplier hiding poor performance or legal issues. Search company name, domain, and social media. Verify consistency in logos, address, and contact info.
No Independent Certifications Risk of non-compliance with EU/US safety regulations (e.g., lead in paints, phthalates in markers). Require lab test reports from accredited facilities. Do not accept self-declared compliance.
Pressure for Full Upfront Payment Common in scams. Legitimate suppliers offer 30% deposit, 70% against BL copy. Use secure payment methods (e.g., LC at sight, Escrow). Never use Western Union.
Generic or Stock Photos Indicates lack of real facility or products. Demand time-stamped photos of your specific order in production.
Overly Broad Product Range A single factory rarely produces high-quality brushes, paints, canvases, and easels. Specialization = expertise. Prioritize suppliers focused on 1–2 art supply categories.

Conclusion & Strategic Recommendations

  1. Prioritize Vertical Integration: Partner with manufacturers controlling key processes (e.g., pigment sourcing + mixing + packaging).
  2. Leverage Third-Party Verification: Budget for pre-audit inspections and PSI—costs are <3% of order value but prevent 80% of quality failures.
  3. Build Long-Term Contracts: Secure capacity and pricing with 12–24 month agreements after successful pilot orders.
  4. Map the Supply Chain: Require full traceability—from raw material suppliers to finished goods—to comply with ESG and CBAM regulations.

Final Note: In 2026, sustainability and compliance are non-negotiable. Verify water treatment systems, ethical labor practices, and carbon footprint disclosures—especially for watercolor and ink manufacturers.


Prepared by:
Senior Sourcing Consultant
SourcifyChina | www.sourcifychina.com
China Sourcing Intelligence for Global Procurement Leaders
Q1 2026 Edition – Confidential for Client Use


Get the Verified Supplier List

SourcifyChina Strategic Sourcing Report: Art Supplies Procurement | 2026 Outlook

Prepared for Global Procurement Leadership | Q1 2026


Executive Summary: The Verification Imperative in Art Supplies Sourcing

Global art supply procurement faces acute volatility in 2026. Rising demand for sustainable materials (up 32% YoY), complex compliance requirements (EU Ecolabel, CPSIA), and persistent supply chain fragmentation have increased supplier vetting costs by 27% for unassisted buyers. SourcifyChina’s Verified Pro List for Wholesale Art Supplies directly mitigates these risks through rigorously audited supplier partnerships, transforming procurement from a cost center to a strategic advantage.


Why the Pro List Cuts Time-to-Value: Data-Driven Efficiency

Traditional sourcing for art supplies requires 8-12 weeks of due diligence per supplier. Our Pro List eliminates 73% of this burden through:

Procurement Stage Traditional Approach SourcifyChina Pro List Time Saved
Supplier Identification 3-5 weeks (RFPs, forums) < 72 hours (Pre-vetted pool) 89%
Quality & Compliance Audit 4-6 weeks (On-site visits) 0 hours (Verified certs: ISO 9001, REACH, ASTM D-4236) 100%
MOQ/Negotiation Validation 2-3 weeks (Trial orders) Immediate (Pre-negotiated terms, avg. 18% cost advantage) 100%
Sustainability Verification 1-2 weeks (Documentation chase) Integrated (FSC®/PEFC-certified materials, carbon-neutral options) 100%
Total Cycle Time 10-16 weeks < 2 weeks 37% avg. reduction

Source: 2025 SourcifyChina Client Performance Benchmark (n=142 procurement teams)


The Strategic Advantage: Beyond Time Savings

  • Risk Mitigation: Zero non-compliant shipments in 2025 for Pro List clients (vs. industry avg. 14.7% failure rate for unverified art supplies).
  • Cost Predictability: Real-time logistics mapping for volatile items (e.g., acrylic pigments, canvas rolls) prevents 22% avg. hidden costs.
  • Innovation Access: Priority onboarding to 47 new eco-material suppliers (e.g., algae-based inks, recycled paper mills) added to the Pro List in Q4 2025.

Call to Action: Secure Your 2026 Procurement Resilience

In a market where one delayed shipment risks $217K in lost retail revenue (per Art Market Monitor), relying on unverified suppliers is no longer operationally viable. The Pro List is not a directory—it’s your embedded sourcing team, validated for your compliance thresholds, volume needs, and sustainability mandates.

→ Act Now to Lock Q1 2026 Capacity:
1. Email: Contact [email protected] with subject line “ART PRO LIST ACCESS – [Your Company]” for immediate eligibility screening.
2. WhatsApp: Message +86 159 5127 6160 for a 15-minute slot to review your top 3 supplier matches. Response within 2 business hours.

Your verified supplier matches will be delivered within 48 hours—including factory audit reports, sample lead times, and tiered pricing structures.


SourcifyChina is the only sourcing partner with ISO 20400 (Sustainable Procurement) certification for Chinese manufacturing ecosystems. All Pro List suppliers undergo bi-annual re-audits by our in-country engineering team.
© 2026 SourcifyChina. Confidential for recipient use only.


🧮 Landed Cost Calculator

Estimate your total import cost from China.

🇨🇳 Factory Sourcing